Главная    Ex Libris    Книги    Журналы    Статьи    Серии    Каталог    Wanted    Загрузка    ХудЛит    Справка    Поиск по индексам    Поиск    Форум   

Поиск по указателям

Anglin W. — Mathematics: A Concise History and Philosophy (Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics / Readings in Mathematics)
Anglin W. — Mathematics: A Concise History and Philosophy (Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics / Readings in Mathematics)

Обсудите книгу на научном форуме

Нашли опечатку?
Выделите ее мышкой и нажмите Ctrl+Enter

Название: Mathematics: A Concise History and Philosophy (Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics / Readings in Mathematics)

Автор: Anglin W.


This book is utterly worthless in every conceivable way. It is a mystery to me why Springer have brought disgrace upon themselves by publishing this inept drivel. A complete account of Anglin's incompetence would require a review as thick as the book itself, but hopefully a few deterring examples will suffice.

First, there are many blatant factual errors, e.g.:

"There were five planets (or so Kepler thought) and five regular polyhedra. This could not be an accident!" (p. 158)

Since Kepler's work on Mars, Jupiter and Saturn are mentioned on the same page, one wonders whether it is Mercury, Venus or the Earth that Anglin imagines Kepler to have been ignorant of.

Other statements cannot even be called false since they are such ludicrous nonsense, e.g.:

"Just as many people before Lobachevsky thought that Euclid's parallel postulate was a kind of sacred truth, so many people before Hamilton thought that the law of commutativity for multiplication was ineluctable. For us it is a commonplace that this law need not hold, since we have a ready example of noncommutativity in matrix multiplication." (p. 195)

The notion that there is some sort of "law" out there about commutativity of multiplication that may or may not hold is a very childish misconception. Whether we call certain operations with matrices and quaternions "multiplication" or not is purely a matter of convention. Thus the alleged "law" that "many people" allegedly held for "ineluctable" has no meaning whatsoever other than as a thoroughly inconsequential claim about naming conventions. Anglin's stupidity is particularly disturbing in light of his immodest description of his own book as offering "a deep penetration into the key mathematical and philosophical aspects of the history of mathematics", "giving the student an opportunity to come to a full and consistent knowledge" (p. viii).

Let us give another example of what Anglin considers to be "a deep penetration" into philosophical issues. We read that "there are various objections to formalism," e.g. that "formalism offers no guarantee that the games of mathematics are consistent." Now, presumably in order to "give the student an opportunity to come to a full and consistent knowledge," Anglin professes to offer the other side of the coin: "the formalist can reply [that] although some of the games of mathematics are indeed inconsistent, and hence trivial, others are not" (pp. 218-219). It is not clear in what sense Anglin fancies the assertion that mathematics is consistent to be a "reply" the the challenge to prove as much.

Finally, the book is full of unsubstantiated revisionist history motivated by unabashed Christian propaganda ("God" is the entry in the index with the most references by far; more, in fact, than Euclid, Archimedes, Newton and Riemann combined), e.g.:

"Most of the mathematicians at the Academy and the Museum rejected the new truths [sic] of Christ's revelation. This is unfortunate because ... if the mathematicians had joined the Christians, the Dark Ages would have been brightened by a dialogue between reason and faith. As it was, this dialogue was postponed to the later Middle Ages, when thinkers like Thomas Aquinas (1225-1275) advanced philosophies that were influenced as much by the Elements as by the Bible." (p. 111)

What a loss for mathematics that we had to wait so many centuries for the great geometer Aquinas!

Язык: en

Рубрика: Математика/

Статус предметного указателя: Указатель в процессе заполнения

ed2k: ed2k stats

Год издания: 1994

Количество страниц: 272

Добавлена в каталог: 14.12.2014

Операции: Положить на полку | Скопировать ссылку для форума | Скопировать ID
Предметный указатель
Предметный индекс пока отсутствует. О том, как ускорить появление предметного индекса можно прочитать на форуме.
       © Электронная библиотека попечительского совета мехмата МГУ, 2004-2021
Электронная библиотека мехмата МГУ | Valid HTML 4.01! | Valid CSS! О проекте